Father Legare led the church until his death in 1885. The Reverend J.L. Dart became the church's second pastor. During his ministry, the membership grew, leading to the organization of Central and Memorial Baptist churches and the expansion of Morris Street Baptist's original building.
The Reverend Randall Kemp was called as the third pastor in 1904. His leadership brought a period of phenomenal growth for the church, both spiritually and physically. A new church was erected in 1909. The membership increased significantly; and at one baptismal service during this period, 93 candidates were baptized.
The Reverend J.C. Dunbar began his 34-year ministry as the fourth pastor in 1922. During his pastorate, many church auxiliaries were formed, including the Board of Trustees, the B.T.U., the Boy and Girl Scout troops, the Brotherhood. The further organization of the Missionary Society and the Sunday School was arranged into departments. The sanctuary was renovated in 1954.
Following the death of Reverend Dunbar, the Reverend J.J. Abney was called as the fifth pastor in 1958. The burning of the renovation mortgage was one of the highlights of his pastorate.
The Reverend Alphonso R. Blake, a Charleston native, was called as the sixth pastor on August 15, 1960, and he began his ministry on January 6, 1961. Dr. Blake led the church through the Civil Rights era.
On February 20, 1964, the historic church, erected in 1909, was destroyed by fire. From 1964 to November 1969, worship services were held at Simonton Elementary School. The church was rebuilt at a cost of $569,000. It was dedicated on November 30, 1969.
To God be the glory!The church continued to grow through outreach programs such as Day Care, Adult Education, Blood Bank, APOD (A Piece of Dignity) - Financial Investment Plan, and a Food Bank. The church was also the site of the South Carolina Baptist Congress of Christian Education.
A ten-year plan, developed in 1975, led to the purchase of property that is now valued at more than $1 million. On February 2, 1983, a ribbon-cutting ceremony was held for the 30-unit J.C. Dunbar Apartments at the former "Do As You Choose Alley." The property was purchased in 1981 and renovated at a cost of $606,847.
From 1987 to 1988, Dr. Blake oversaw the installation of stained glass windows and a general refurbishing of the sanctuary. Dr. Blake elected the first three female trustees to the Board. They were Joe Ethel Moore, Evelyn Richards and Eunice Waddy.
During Dr. Blake's tenure, he ordained a number of new pastors. Among them were the Reverends Amos Jones, Peter Lucas, J. Keith Carter, Wayne Carter, Cecil Diggs, Frank Lee, Jesse Hudson, Brister Davis, Isaac J. Holt Jr. and Evan Lee.
Dr. Blake ordained as deacons Rufus Behrens, Walter Richards, Alfonso J. Evans Sr., Frank Smith, Jake Brown, George Washington, Alphonso Sumter, Thomas Brown, Samuel Evans, Melvin VanBuren, Benjamin Middleton and Theodore R. Hartwell Jr.
The church observed its 125th anniversary in 1990. It marked the publication of the first hard cover souvenir journal of the church. The volume provides a complete history of the church and will serve as a permanent record of the first 125 years of Morris Street Baptist Church.
The church's progress did not stop with this historic milestone. The former parsonage building at 23 Morris Street was renovated for use as the offices for the J.C. Dunbar Apartments, and as additional space for the Sunday School. An elevator was installed and dedicated on May 26, 1991. A Nurses' Unit was formed in July 1991.
In March 1993, a severe windstorm caused major damage to the roof. It forced the congregation to move temporarily to the Fine Arts Center at Burke High School while repairs were made. The building was rededicated in October 1993.
Because of serious deterioration of the lower level of the building, major structural renovations were made in late 1996 and they were completed in March 1997. That same year, a "chair lift" to assist handicapped persons was installed, and other improvements were made to the grounds and the parking areas.
Today, the church is affiliated with the Charleston County Missionary Baptist Association, the Baptist Education and Missionary Convention of South Carolina, the Baptist Woman's Educational and Missionary Convention and its Auxiliaries, and the National Baptist Convention.
The Reverend Leonard O. Griffin became the church's seventh pastor on March 6, 2005. A native of Edgefield, South Carolina, Reverend Griffin came to Morris Street Baptist from Southern Missionary Baptist Church in Syracuse, N.Y.
Reverend Griffin considers it an honor to follow in Dr. Blake's footsteps. "Reverend Blake was here for 42 years," he said. "I had known of him since I started in the ministry. When the call came for me to come here, I had a pretty good sense of what he meant to this church and to the state of South Carolina. My task, now, is to build upon that legacy."